Up and coming Red Sox star Tony Conigliaro shares a moment with the Giants' Hall of Famer Willie Mays. Conigliaro had his promising career cut short by a terrible eye injury when he was hit at the plate in 1967. Awards: Mays: Hall of Fame, All-Star ( 24x ), All-Star MVP ( 2x ), World Series Champion, NL MVP ( 2x ), NL Rookie of the Year, Gold Glove ( 12x ), NL Batting Champion. Conigliaro: All-Star.